During the Rolling Road tests a 4-Gas test was also done.
In my, then newly acquired, experience doing a RR without hooking
up a 4-Gas-tester doesn't have much point.
The graphs show you what goes wrong (lack of power at a certain
power-range), but the information on the burnt (or not) gasses
tell you what may be going wrong.
Unfortunately the 4-gas tester wasn't an integral part of the RR-testbench. As a result it's not possible to superimpose the data of the 4-Gas test to that of the RR. The 'raw data' was given to me on a printout and entered in a spreadsheet to produce the following graphs:
By using one of the RR graphs that's also plotted against time (the x-axle on the graphs above are seconds), one might be able to get some reference points, but it would be hard to find an exact starting point (second #1 in the above graphs was not the same point in one of the runs). As it is the starting points of the graphs above were used to 'overlay' the various graphs in one picture.
What these graphs do seem to show is a
consistency in readings.
It doesn't look like there is a problem in 4th gear that's not
there in 3rd or All gears.
To better understand what these readings were telling me I did some searching on the Net and found the following documents that explain a thing or two on combustion gasses;
Chemistry Of
CombustionChemistryOfCombustion_h55.pdf |
Emission AnalysisEmissionAnalysis_h56.pdf |
Five Gas AnalysisFiveGasAnalysis_hg2.pdf |
Emission Systems
& Control250.Emission.2 Oswego State U |
So what did this tell me ?
HC value
This is basically the amount of unburned fuel that's coming out
the back.
For my Van it should be around 400ppm. As you can see in the raw data, the initial value was some
2400 or 6(!) times as much as it should be.
As the value never came close to 400 this (partly) explained the
'afterburners' in my tailpipe.
This value is a bastard to trace as it can have all sorts of
causes, ranging from to lean or to rich a mixture to mechanical
problems.
CO value
The CO value indicates partially unburned fuel.
This one is much easier to trace as it's always a result of a
mixture that was too rich; there wasn't enough O2 (Oxygen) to
convert to CO2 exhaust gas only.
During the year 'MOT' the CO value is measured.
My Van can get away with 4.5% but the Haynes manual mentions a
value between 1,5 and 3%. Usually this means the carb settings
have to be tweaked a bit before testing, as it doesn't really run
well on too lean a mixture. There was no initial CO value given,
it was measured during the RR tests.
CO2 value
As mentioned above, CO2 is what you want to come out of your
exhaust as it's the end result of a good burn; the higher the
better.
It's linked to the CO value, but can also be influenced by other
factors and thus is a bit harder to trace.
I haven't found a reference yet as to what the CO2 level should
be for my Van.
O2 value
O2 is Oxygen. Any of this coming out of the tailpipe is a waste
basically; it could have been used to burn more fuel.
Too much O2 is often an indication of a lean mixture or an
airleak.
Lambda value
As the above documents explain, the Lambda value is a calculated
value.
Since my Van is an 1980 model and not equipped with a cat it's
not of much interest here.
Looking at the data it shows that the HC, CO and O2 values are
too high.
Strangely enough the test run where it all went 'south', in 4th
gear, is the one showing the best values for HC, CO and O2.
As the RR run in 4th gear indicated something seriously (as in mayor, not really serious as in may kill the engine) wrong, I decided to have that sorted first and then see what the values would be. As it is the values do not clearly point out a certain failure that could be causing the problem.
Data 20020316 | |||||||||||||
CO2 | 4,3 | % | |||||||||||
HC | 2432 | PPM | |||||||||||
O2 | 9,92 | % | |||||||||||
LBV | 17,9 | ||||||||||||
Lambda | 1,219 | ||||||||||||
3rd Gear | 4th Gear | All Gear | |||||||||||
CO | CO2 | HC | O2 | CO | CO2 | HC | O2 | CO | CO2 | HC | O2 | ||
7,22 | 7,6 | 1470 | 4,08 | 5,79 | 8,8 | 998 | 3,94 | 6,84 | 6,9 | 1525 | 5,43 | ||
7,31 | 7,5 | 1530 | 4,21 | 5,72 | 8,9 | 961 | 3,94 | 6,88 | 6,9 | 1522 | 5,43 | ||
7,43 | 7,4 | 1597 | 4,35 | 5,69 | 9,1 | 928 | 3,81 | 7,15 | 7,0 | 1475 | 5,30 | ||
7,52 | 7,4 | 1589 | 4,35 | 5,97 | 9,1 | 877 | 3,53 | 7,42 | 7,1 | 1440 | 5,17 | ||
7,72 | 7,4 | 1554 | 4,21 | 6,33 | 9,0 | 854 | 3,40 | 7,77 | 7,1 | 1438 | 4,62 | ||
8,47 | 7,3 | 1444 | 3,94 | 7,18 | 8,7 | 816 | 3,12 | 7,90 | 7,1 | 1459 | 4,62 | ||
8,83 | 7,2 | 1377 | 3,67 | 7,64 | 8,5 | 800 | 2,99 | 8,09 | 7,1 | 1467 | 4,48 | ||
9,42 | 7,1 | 1257 | 3,40 | 8,14 | 8,3 | 785 | 2,85 | 8,70 | 7,1 | 1421 | 4,08 | ||
9,64 | 7,1 | 1204 | 3,26 | 9,09 | 7,8 | 758 | 2,58 | 9,12 | 7,1 | 1378 | 3,81 | ||
9,87 | 7,1 | 1150 | 3,12 | 9,50 | 7,6 | 757 | 2,58 | 9,81 | 6,9 | 1352 | 3,26 | ||
10,30 | 7,1 | 1069 | 2,72 | 9,89 | 7,4 | 747 | 2,44 | 9,88 | 6,7 | 1433 | 3,12 | ||
10,57 | 7,0 | 1032 | 2,58 | 10,68 | 7,0 | 732 | 2,44 | 9,81 | 6,6 | 1581 | 3,12 | ||
11,21 | 6,8 | 972 | 2,31 | 11,02 | 6,8 | 720 | 2,31 | 9,70 | 6,6 | 1798 | 3,67 | ||
11,57 | 6,7 | 941 | 2,03 | 11,45 | 6,7 | 707 | 2,17 | 9,82 | 6,6 | 1809 | 3,67 | ||
11,87 | 6,6 | 913 | 2,03 | 11,49 | 6,6 | 702 | 2,17 | 10,03 | 6,7 | 1783 | 3,53 | ||
12,50 | 6,4 | 864 | 1,76 | 11,53 | 6,7 | 696 | 2,03 | 10,63 | 6,7 | 1676 | 3,12 | ||
12,74 | 6,3 | 846 | 1,64 | 11,44 | 6,8 | 686 | 2,03 | 10,97 | 6,6 | 1615 | 2,85 | ||
13,12 | 6,1 | 814 | 1,50 | 11,40 | 6,9 | 685 | 1,90 | 11,45 | 6,6 | 1500 | 2,44 | ||
13,14 | 6,1 | 769 | 1,36 | 11,35 | 6,9 | 679 | 1,90 | 11,48 | 6,6 | 1442 | 2,31 | ||
12,91 | 6,3 | 780 | 1,36 | 11,36 | 7,0 | 676 | 1,76 | 11,18 | 6,8 | 1386 | 2,17 | ||
11,58 | 6,7 | 765 | 1,50 | 11,41 | 7,0 | 679 | 1,76 | 9,72 | 7,3 | 1305 | 2,17 | ||
11,59 | 7,0 | 674 | 1,64 | 9,08 | 7,6 | 1289 | 2,31 | ||||||
11,72 | 7,0 | 674 | 1,50 | 8,14 | 8,1 | 1230 | 2,85 | ||||||
12,09 | 6,8 | 667 | 1,36 | 7,66 | 8,4 | 1187 | 2,85 | ||||||
12,28 | 6,8 | 663 | 1,36 | 7,14 | 8,8 | 1143 | 2,85 | ||||||
12,49 | 6,7 | 664 | 1,36 | 5,98 | 9,6 | 1042 | 2,72 | ||||||
12,85 | 6,5 | 655 | 1,23 | 5,47 | 10,0 | 997 | 2,58 | ||||||
13,07 | 6,4 | 651 | 1,23 | 4,44 | 10,6 | 910 | 2,58 | ||||||
13,37 | 6,2 | 638 | 1,09 | 3,99 | 10,9 | 866 | 2,58 | ||||||
13,37 | 6,2 | 632 | 1,09 | 3,58 | 11,1 | 827 | 2,58 | ||||||
13,15 | 6,3 | 621 | 1,09 | 2,85 | 11,3 | 767 | 2,72 | ||||||
11,65 | 7,1 | 604 | 1,09 | 2,56 | 11,5 | 740 | 2,85 | ||||||
10,45 | 7,6 | 588 | 1,09 |